Nicolet Bankshares

NIC on NYSE. Nicolet Bankshares sells loans, deposits and banking services to people and businesses. Market value $3.5bn.

Watch this stockFree. We tell you when something changes.

Price checks use the past 12 months to June 2026. Some use the latest annual report instead, as marked. Quality checks use five annual reports, the latest for the year to December 2025.

Should I look at this?

Worth a closer look

Read what could go wrong

This is not advice. Check the numbers below.

Compare with another stock

Return on equity
five annual reports to December 2025
10.1%five-year median

Yearly profit per dollar of owners' money: 10 cents. Above 10 is good.

Price to book
quarterly report to June 2026
1.5×

What you pay for each dollar of net assets: $1.52.

Earnings yield
past 12 months to June 2026
4.5%

Profit per $100 you pay: $4.47.

Quality score: 89 of 100. Price score: 64 of 100. Our list needs 70 on quality and 60 on price.

$164.62 a share, 44% above its 1-year low

Over the past year the price has ranged from $114.12 to $180.00.

Dividend: 0.5% a year

Paid every year for 3 years

Payouts have jumped around in recent years, so this may not repeat.

Prices from Monday’s close (5 October).

Five years of cash, in billions

n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
20212022202320242025
Revenue
n/an/an/an/an/a
Operating margin
n/an/an/an/an/a
Debt to equity
n/an/an/an/an/a
Shares outstanding
0.01bn0.01bn0.02bn0.01bn0.02bn

Health checks

  • Free cash flow positiveDoesn't apply to banks and insurers
  • Accounting checksDoesn't apply to banks and insurers
  • DebtDoesn't apply to banks and insurers
  • Revenue growth, five yearsUnknown
  • Buying back its own sharesNo, 43% more shares since 2021

The quarter to June 2026

How the business did, compared with the same quarter a year earlier.

  • Profit: $57 million, up 58% on a year ago.
  • 41% more shares than a year ago. Each share owns a bit less of the company.
Profit by quarter
Profit by quarter
Quarter toAmount
September 2024$33m
December 2024$34m
March 2025$33m
June 2025$36m
September 2025$42m
December 2025$40m
March 2026$15m
June 2026$57m

From the company's quarterly reports to the SEC.

Dates

Next results (estimated)
n/a
Last annual report (10-K)
27 February 2026
Next quarterly (estimated, 10-Q)
30 October 2026

Who owns it

3 long-term investors we follow own it, down from 4 last quarter. 254 funds in all.

Jun '25
Dec '25
Jun '26

Sold out this quarter

Largest holders overall

From 13F filings for the quarter ended 30 June 2026.

Big holders and activists

2 investors own more than 5%.

From Schedule 13D and 13G filings: anyone owning more than 5% must file one.

What insiders did

In the last 12 months, 3 insiders bought $390,770 of shares on the open market. 2 sold $3m.

  • Witczak Eric James
    EVP - Retail & Ag Banking
    Sold
    Date
    28 July 2026
    Shares
    342
    Price
    $171.96
    Value
    $58,810
  • Witczak Eric James
    EVP - Retail & Ag Banking
    Sold
    Date
    27 July 2026
    Shares
    1,215
    Price
    $167.89
    Value
    $203,986
  • ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE
    Director
    Sold
    Date
    24 July 2026
    Shares
    2,662
    Price
    $170.24
    Value
    $453,179
  • ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE
    Director
    Sold
    Date
    12 March 2026
    Shares
    3,309
    Price
    $149.82
    Value
    $495,760
  • ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE
    Director
    Sold
    Date
    5 March 2026
    Shares
    3,331
    Price
    $150.67
    Value
    $501,888
  • ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE
    Director
    Sold
    Date
    18 February 2026
    Shares
    6,396
    Price
    $155.47
    Value
    $994,386
  • MOORE HUBERT PHILLIP JR
    CFO
    Bought
    Date
    18 November 2025
    Shares
    25
    Price
    $120.35
    Value
    $3,009
  • Ghidorzi Christopher J.
    Director
    Bought
    Date
    4 November 2025
    Shares
    105
    Price
    $121.52
    Value
    $12,760
  • WEYERS ROBERT J
    Director
    Bought
    Date
    30 October 2025
    Shares
    3,000
    Price
    $115.73
    Value
    $347,200
  • MOORE HUBERT PHILLIP JR
    CFO
    Bought
    Date
    30 October 2025
    Shares
    240
    Price
    $115.84
    Value
    $27,802

From Form 4 filings: insiders must report trades in their own company's shares within two days.

Warning signs in its filings

Problems the company itself reported to the SEC, in its own words.

None of the warning signs we check for were found.

We look for five warning signs: doubt it can keep going, weak checks on its own accounts, a notice that its past accounts can't be relied on, a change of auditor, and one customer bringing in a big share of sales. We don't check lawsuits, investigations or debt yet.

We checked the auditor's report, internal controls, restatement notices, auditor changes and big customers in the 10-K filed 27 Feb 2026, plus the 10-Q filed 31 Jul 2026 and 3 later 8-Ks.

A 10-K is the yearly report every US company files with the SEC. An 8-K is a short notice of a big event.

What could go wrong

Cheap for a reason is the question the numbers cannot answer.

Whether the price already reflects the risks is what the deep dive is for.

What changed in the risks this year

Companies must list what could hurt them each year. These are the parts that changed since last year’s report.

  • Federal Reserve strategies can, and often are intended to, affect the domestic money supply, inflation, interest rates, and the shape of the yield curve. These strategies have had, and will continue to have, a significant impact on our business and on many of our customers.

    Already happened
    After substantially increasing interest rates in 2022 and much of 2023, in response to inflationary pressures, beginning with third quarter 2024, the Federal Reserve began to decrease interest rates. Expected changes in the composition of the Federal Reserve Board, including its chairman, and continuing volatility in the economy, increases the uncertainty of future Federal Reserve actions with respect to interest rates. Fluctuations in interest rates have had and may continue to have significant and sometimes adverse effects upon our business as well as the business of many of our customers.
    Read more
  • Political dysfunction and volatility within the federal government, both at the regulatory and Congressional level, creates significant potential for major and abrupt shifts in federal policy regarding bank regulation, taxes, and the economy, any of which could have significant and adverse impacts on our business and financial performance.

    Could happen
    In addition, the current Presidential administration and Congress are expected to significantly change the priorities, scope, practices and/or staffing levels of various regulatory agencies, including the CFPB. As a result, state attorneys general and other state regulators may increase their enforcement activities to fill any actual or perceived “regulatory gap” at the federal level and seek to obtain remedies such as regulatory sanctions, customer rescission rights and civil money penalties. Such uncertainties may make it more difficult for us to comply with consumer protection laws, which may result in increased compliance costs and potential non-compliance and associated regulatory actions. Any regulatory actions against us could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations.
    Read more

Read it in the annual report

The deep dive

Everything above is arithmetic on public filings. The deep dive reads the last ten years of annual reports, the proxy statements, and the earnings calls, then argues the case the way Buffett, Klarman, and Hohn would, and checks every claim against the source.

  • What the business is worth, as a range, and the margin of safety at today’s price
  • Prices to start buying, buy, and buy hard
  • The three things that would make this a mistake
  • Every number footnoted to the filing it came from
Create a free account to run it

Your first deep dive is free.

What a finished deep dive looks like

Not advice. Numbers on this page come from SEC filings and are updated each night; prices are updated again after the US market closes. The five-year figures are rounded.